Feb 26, 2025

*Two young girls, best friends Ashley Pond and Miranda Gaddis, go missing two months apart from each other. Law enforcement is stumped. Had the girls planned some sort of elaborate disappearing act and run away? Or is something more sinister going on? 

*Listener, Synthia, suggested case!

Sign up for your free Patreon...

Feb 19, 2025

Emily and Joe Ferlazzo take off on a trip into the Green Mountains of Vermont to celebrate their one-year wedding anniversary. But only one of them, Joe, returns home … with Emily now missing, and the Vermont State Police searching for answers. With eerie similarities to the Gaby Petito case, law enforcement takes...

Feb 14, 2025

It’s the middle of the night. Crystal Lake, Illinois. A house is on fire. A neighbor breaks in and saves a baby from the flames … but as firefighters head in to put out the inferno,  they discover the body of a popular teenager inside the bathroom–and a murder inquiry begins.

Welcome to a bonus feature here on...

Feb 12, 2025

A van with eight people shows up one day at an autistic man’s house. An argument ensues. By the end of the day, Hayden Garreffa’s family reports him missing … desperate to find him before something horrible happens. Pennsylvania State Police get involved and soon have a lead, as one of the most shocking crimes in...

Feb 5, 2025

It’s 1981. A young woman, Debra Miller, living alone in a Mansfield, Ohio, apartment is found brutally murdered. With two other murders reported in the months before, it’s possible a serial killer is at large. Yet, several Mansfield cops are so deeply immersed in committing crimes themselves, 40 years goes by before...